Book 2 · Chapter 1 · Scene 2

Choosing the Road

They did not leave Beregost’s temple yard quickly.

For a while, there was no reason to.

The old camp field lay beyond the buildings, visible in broken slices between roofs, carts, and the ordinary movement of people who still needed supper, wages, wood, water, errands, sleep. Evening kept lowering itself over the town. Chimneys breathed. A dog barked twice and was scolded into silence. Somewhere behind them, Halver’s voice returned to names, lists, and the small brutal arithmetic of care.

Maeril stood beside Ṛṣi until the light changed enough that the field’s scars became less distinct.

Then she said, “If I keep staring at that patch of grass, I am going to start assigning moral significance to weeds.”

Ṛṣi turned his head slightly.

“Would you be wrong?”

“That is not the point.” She adjusted her cloak with unnecessary sharpness. “The point is that I am hungry, tired, and dangerously close to respecting local governance.”

“That does sound serious.”

“It is. Take me somewhere with bread before I recover.”

So he did.

They found a small tavern on a side street, not the loudest place near the trade road and not the quietest either. The common room was clean in the way working rooms became clean after long practice rather than wealth: swept boards, scrubbed tables, smoke-dark beams, a hearth low enough not to waste wood. A few merchants murmured over cups. Two drovers argued without energy near the back wall. The smell was watered ale, onions, roasted turnips, old beer, wet wool, and bread pulled from an oven earlier than anyone wished.

They took a table near the wall.

Packs went down beside them with soft thuds. Maeril’s landed with the particular exhausted accusation of a thing that believed it had been mistreated by physics. Ṛṣi set his staff where his hand could find it without thought.

For a few breaths, neither spoke.

The tavern’s noise gathered around them and did not quite enter.

Bread came. Vegetables. A small bowl of beans with enough salt to pretend generosity. Watered ale that Maeril sniffed once and did not insult aloud, which Ṛṣi marked as restraint of a high order.

She tore bread with both hands and stared at the table.

“Better than I feared,” she said at last. “Worse than I wanted. Which is usually what happens when people get involved.”

Ṛṣi nodded.

Maeril ate one bite, chewed, and frowned toward the room as if the tavern had personally arranged moral ambiguity for her inconvenience.

“I hate that I’m relieved,” she said. “The field is empty. Some are housed. Some found work. Some moved on. Halver has become the kind of man who can weaponize shame against a council, which I approve of spiritually.”

Another bite.

“And still. Some died.”

“Yes.”

She looked at him over the bread.

He had answered too cleanly.

Not coldly. Never that. But the word had come from a place already ordered and sealed, as if he had accepted the fact, placed it where grief belonged, and moved on to the next necessary thing before she had finished standing in the first.

Maeril narrowed her eyes.

Ṛṣi’s hands rested near his cup. Not wrapped around it. Near it. His thumb touched the side of one finger, then stilled. His gaze had gone to the packs, to the staff, to the door, to the road beyond the tavern he could not see from where he sat.

Not watching for danger.

Counting.

There it was.

Maeril sat back.

“Oh,” she said.

Ṛṣi looked at her. “Oh?”

“You have gone quiet in the way that means your hands are trying to solve your life before your mouth gets involved.”

His eyes lowered to his hands.

That proved her point so thoroughly that she almost smiled.

Almost.

“What are you measuring?” she asked.

“I am not measuring.”

“Rish.”

The private name landed between them softly enough that the drovers did not hear it, and sharply enough that he did.

He exhaled through his nose.

Maeril reached for her ale, thought better of it after a second sniff, and took water instead.

“There it is,” she said. “The monastery behind your eyes.”

His mouth twitched. Not quite humor. Not quite surrender.

“I was thinking.”

“Dangerous. About what?”

He looked toward the door again. A cart passed outside, wheels knocking over uneven stone.

“Lantern Hall,” he said.

There.

The word entered the room.

Maeril did not pounce. She only waited.

“Elisa will have kept the routines,” he continued. “But I should know what changed while we were gone. Supplies. Cots. Volunteers. Whether the east roof still leaks when the rain turns from the river. Whether the new intake shelf remained where it could be reached.”

His fingers touched the staff once, then left it.

“I have not trained properly in days. Not the full sequence. Candlekeep had space, but not the right ground. The road changes things. Inns change things. I should rebuild the pattern before I lose too much of it.”

Maeril watched him list himself back into existence.

Lantern Hall. Supplies. Roof. Shelf. Training. Ground. Pattern.

All true things.

All useful things.

All of them arranged like stones across a river he did not want to admit he was afraid to cross.

“And after that?” she asked.

He looked at her.

“After what?”

“After you check the roof, realign the shelves, bow to every blanket in Lantern Hall, and beat yourself back into the precise shape expected of you by mud, dawn, and self-inflicted discipline.”

A short silence followed.

The corner of his mouth moved.

“You make it sound excessive.”

“I am being generous.”

He took a drink, giving himself time. Ṛṣi did that when a truth had teeth. He did not lie. He did not deflect well. He simply found the nearest useful silence and stood inside it until speech could be made safe.

Maeril leaned forward.

“Do you want to go back?”

His gaze lifted to hers.

The question was too simple for what it held.

He answered too honestly for comfort.

“Yes.”

Maeril felt the small thing in her chest tighten before she could stop it.

Then he added, “And no.”

There he was.

She set her bread down.

Outside, Beregost settled deeper into evening. Someone laughed in the street. A door shut. The tavern keeper wiped the same piece of counter three times because there were no customers at that exact spot and habit needed somewhere to go.

Ṛṣi looked at his hands.

“Lantern Hall matters,” he said. “Elisa matters. The work matters.”

“Yes.”

“I know the shape of that life.”

“I know.”

His thumb brushed the scarred edge of the table. “I know where to stand. When to rise. How to train before the doors open. Which sounds mean fever, and which mean fear, and which mean someone has hidden pain because they do not want to be made trouble. I know where the bandages are without looking. I know how the Hall breathes.”

Maeril was quiet now.

He rarely gave this much at once.

His voice stayed plain, but the plainness had weight.

“Candlekeep had a shape too,” he said. “Different. Temporary. But real. Work in the morning. Reading. Copying. Walking. Training where I could. You arguing with books as if they had insulted you.”

“They often had.”

“Yes.”

A breath.

“Now that shape is gone.”

Maeril looked at him, and the teasing left her face by degrees.

He did not look lost. That would have been easier to name.

He looked like a man standing in an empty practice yard after the bell had been removed, waiting for his body to be told what hour it was.

Change was not new to him. Road, cell, monastery, battlefield, Hall, Candlekeep. He had survived change by making form inside it. Breath. Staff. Work. Routine. Service. The next necessary thing.

Now the next necessary thing was unclear, and the unclear place had her in it.

Maeril’s throat tightened.

She reached for humor because it was safer than touching the raw place with bare hands.

“So your plan was to quietly become a duty roster and hope I didn’t notice.”

“I did not have a plan.”

“That is worse. An accidental duty roster is the saddest kind.”

That time, he did smile. Small. Tired. Real.

Then it faded.

“What do you want?” he asked.

The question turned too quickly.

Maeril glanced away.

There was the stall.

Her stall.

Her counter. Her patched canopy. Her pot. The bridge children who pretended not to wait for accidents of bread. Regulars who complained about seasoning and came back the next day anyway. The hawk’s old circle over Wyrm’s Crossing. The river wind. The doorless hut. The life she had made because nobody had handed her one and she had grown tired of asking places to let her belong.

She loved parts of it with a fierceness that made her angry.

That was the trouble.

She could see herself returning. She could see her hands on the ladle, her books shoved into the safest corner, her jokes ready before dawn, her tail keeping balance behind the counter, her eyes finding every hungry child before the child had to ask.

She could also see herself pretending that Candlekeep had been an errand.

That the road had been a detour.

That the book, the long nights, the firelight, the conversations, the way Ṛṣi looked at a page until mercy found structure there, the way her own magic had opened under being understood—none of it had altered the size of her life.

Her mouth twisted.

“Back to the stall,” she said, “and pretend nothing’s changed?”

Ṛṣi watched her.

“Take what we’ve learned and wedge it back into the old shape?”

The words came sharper than she meant.

Good.

Sharp was easier to survive than trembling.

“I can go back,” she said. “I should, at some point. I know that. I know who eats there. I know who will pretend they did not miss me. I know which child will have decided the corner of the counter belongs to him now because I was foolish enough to leave an empire unattended.”

Her fingers tightened around the cup.

“But if I go back now, I think I will have to lie. Not with words. Worse. With routine.”

Ṛṣi said nothing.

That was one of the ways she loved him: he did not rush to rescue a truth before it finished hurting.

Maeril looked down at the table between them.

“I don’t want to make Candlekeep small enough to fit behind my soup pot.”

The line surprised her.

It surprised him too. She saw it in the minute stillness of his hands.

Then he nodded once.

“No.”

That was all.

No sermon. No permission. No beautiful answer.

Just no.

It steadied her more than a speech would have.

“What about you?” she asked, quieter. “Not the roof. Not the shelves. Not the sacred position of the bandages. You.”

He took longer this time.

His eyes moved to the staff at his side. The wood rested against the wall, familiar and changed by the road, by her hands, by the work they had done together. His fingers opened once on the table, then closed lightly.

“I do not want to abandon Lantern Hall,” he said.

“I know.”

“I do not want Elisa to think I can leave because what we built matters less.”

“She won’t.”

“She may feel it before she knows otherwise.”

Maeril did not argue.

Feelings did not wait for doctrine.

Ṛṣi looked at her then. Fully.

“And I do not want to return as if the road ended at Candlekeep.”

Something in her chest went very still.

He seemed to hear the shape of what he had said only after saying it.

His gaze dropped again.

“I feel unfinished,” he said.

The tavern noise softened around the words.

Not vanished. Nothing so dramatic. A mug struck wood near the hearth. Someone coughed. The drovers had lowered their argument into grunts.

But the words made their own room.

“As if the road we stepped onto has not yet run its length,” Ṛṣi said. “Not because I know where it goes. I do not. Not because I seek danger. I do not.”

Maeril’s eyebrow rose.

He noticed.

“I do not seek danger unnecessarily.”

“Better.”

His mouth almost moved again, but the seriousness held.

“When I think of returning now,” he said, “I can see the work. I can see where to stand. But I cannot see how to stand there unchanged.”

Maeril swallowed.

He had found it.

Not I want you.

Not let us run.

Not love over duty.

Something truer for him.

The old form could not hold the whole of what had happened.

Not yet.

She reached across the table, slowly enough that he could refuse if he needed to.

He did not.

Her fingers touched the back of his hand, not claiming, not dramatic. Warm skin. Ink-stains faded from Candlekeep still shadowing one nail. A small scar near one knuckle she did not remember from before and would ask about later, when it was safe to make him endure being noticed.

“Then we’re between things,” she said.

He looked at her hand on his.

“Not where we were,” she said. “Not yet where we’re going.”

His thumb shifted once.

Barely.

Enough to answer.

“That is an uncomfortable place to stand.”

“Story of my life.”

That earned the smallest breath of laughter from him.

Good.

She held his hand one moment longer, then released it before the room could become too aware of them.

The watered ale waited. Mediocre, warm at the edges, entirely unworthy of history.

Maeril lifted her cup anyway.

“Then we choose the road,” she said.

Ṛṣi looked up.

She kept her voice low. No ceremony. No theater. Just the truth placed where both of them could see it.

“Not forever,” she said. “Not abandonment. Not running so far south that Elisa has to send Lathander himself to drag you back by the ear.”

He blinked.

“She would,” Maeril said.

“She would not send Lathander.”

“No. She would come herself. Worse.”

That one almost made him smile fully.

Maeril’s own smile softened before she could sharpen it again.

“Just next,” she said.

The words landed.

Not forever.

Just next.

Ṛṣi looked at the cup in her hand, then at the road-dark window, then at her.

He lifted his own cup.

“To not knowing,” Maeril said, “and to walking anyway.”

Ṛṣi touched his cup to hers.

A small sound.

Clay against clay.

“To walking,” he said. “And listening.”

They drank.

The ale was terrible.

Maeril closed her eyes for one offended heartbeat.

“Beregost continues to test my mercy.”

“You chose the road before tasting it.”

“Then this is your fault.”

“I see.”

“You do not, but you will.”

The warmth returned slowly.

Not enough to erase what had been said.

Enough to let it live.

For a little while, they ate.

The decision sat between them, quiet and enormous, disguised as supper.

Outside, Beregost’s lamps came on one by one. The town no longer looked like a question they had failed to answer. It looked like a place they had passed through once, wounded; a place that had kept living; a place that had given them something they had not expected.

Permission, perhaps.

Not an answer.

But enough.

Maeril leaned back at last and nudged one of her packs with her boot.

It did not move.

She nudged harder.

The pack remained where it was, dense with books, notes, ink, small tools, wrapped packets, and whatever else a wizard insisted was essential to survival because the world had not yet apologized for being inconvenient.

Her expression darkened.

“Unfortunately,” she said, “the road appears to have opinions about weight.”

Ṛṣi followed her gaze to the pack.

Then to the second pack.

Then to the smaller satchel that had somehow become attached to the first two by straps, buckles, cord, and Maeril’s refusal to admit defeat.

“I see.”

“No,” she said. “You do not. You own a staff and three moral principles.”

“Four.”

“Worse.”

She leaned forward and pointed at the nearest bag as if accusing it before a magistrate.

“If we are choosing the road, the road will have to learn that wizardry has needs.”

Ṛṣi looked at the pack again.

It had begun, slightly, to lean.

He reached out and set it upright before it could collapse against the wall.

Maeril watched him do it, then looked at his nearly empty travel bundle with open resentment.

“This,” she said, “is going to become a theological problem.”

The decision held.

The world returned.

And beneath bread crumbs, bad ale, too many books, and a road not yet paid for, the new shape of their life took one quiet step south.

Canonical website for The Monk & The Witch: monkandwitch.com. If this text appears elsewhere with ads, payment gates, altered attribution, or misleading claims, it is not the canonical edition.

The Monk and the Witch is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. It is not approved or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. © Wizards of the Coast LLC.