Book 1 · Chapter 5 · Scene 5

What Leaves

By morning, the room had begun turning back into a room.

Not theirs.

Not quite.

The borrowed books were gone first, returned the evening before under Lethan’s supervision and Maeril’s theatrical mourning. Then the loose diagrams vanished into cases. Then the folded clothes, ink pots, spare cords, letters, travel pouches, oilcloth wraps, and the small domestic debris of six months chosen in one place.

Maeril’s notes resisted packing with the moral force of living creatures.

“This one is still active thought,” she said, rescuing a page from Ṛṣi’s careful stack.

“It is a list of warding failures.”

“Exactly. Active thought.”

“This one says only, ‘No, but worse.’”

“And I stand by it.”

Ṛṣi folded Elisa’s latest letter and placed it with the others. The packet had grown thick through winter and spring: Lantern Hall standing, worrying, arguing about blankets, becoming more itself without his hands on every wall.

Near the door, the new staff leaned beside his travel bundle.

It did not look like his old staff, even though his old wraps bound the grip. It did not look like Maeril’s either, though her warding slept in the grain. Pale livingwood, narrow carved channels, quiet abjuration lines under the surface. Too new to belong there. Too important to leave behind.

Ṛṣi’s eyes returned to it more often than he meant them to.

Maeril saw, of course.

She always saw the thing he had not decided whether to name.

“You keep looking at it like it might bite.”

“It might.”

“It will not bite unless I add that later.”

He looked at her.

“That was not reassuring.”

“I withheld several worse answers. Appreciate my restraint.”

He crossed to the staff and took it in hand.

The grip fit.

That still unsettled him.

Not because it was wrong. Because it was right in a way he had not yet learned to trust. His hands knew where to rest. The staff answered weight and balance with quiet readiness. But beneath that readiness lay another presence: Maeril’s fear, craft, and refusal to let distance have the final word.

It was a gift.

It was also a responsibility.

“What do you call it?” he asked.

Maeril stopped pretending to fight a strap.

“I considered several dramatic names and rejected all of them because I am tasteful under pressure.”

“Maeril.”

“The Staff of Warding.”

The name settled between them.

Plain. Useful. Difficult to misunderstand.

Ṛṣi turned the staff once.

“The Staff of Warding,” he repeated.

“Yes.” She lifted her chin. “If anyone proposes something more poetic, I will become unbearable.”

“You are already unbearable.”

“With support.”

He looked at her.

Her smile held for one heartbeat too long, then softened.

“Still strange?” she asked.

“Yes.”

“Good.”

That surprised him.

Maeril returned to the satchel, tightening a buckle with unnecessary force.

“If it already felt ordinary, I would be insulted.”

“It is not ordinary.”

“No.” Her voice lowered. “It is not.”

For a moment, the room held both of them and all the things that had happened there: winter cold at the shutters, paper birds, books on the bed, ink on skin, Maeril asleep in the wrong direction across the blankets, Ṛṣi listening to the sea below the walls, both of them learning how long a season could become when chosen.

Then Maeril snapped the satchel closed.

“Right. Before I grow sentimental and ruin my reputation, we should go say goodbye to extremely dangerous people.”


The Emerald Door opened for them more easily now.

That did not make Maeril forgive it.

They passed through together, the Staff of Warding in Ṛṣi’s hand and Master Olan’s folded note tucked between Maeril’s fingers. The deeper passages received them with the same cool restraint they had always had: less light, sealed doors, stone underfoot, and the particular Candlekeep quiet that made even breathing feel subject to review.

Maeril glanced once at the green-lit threshold as it settled closed behind them.

“I still think it should apologize.”

Ṛṣi looked at the Door.

“For opening?”

“For taking so long to become reasonable.”

“It may believe we were the slow part.”

“Then it is rude as well as smug.”

The corner of his mouth moved.

They met Selanka where Ṛṣi had spent so many hours learning what books could do to a person.

She waited beside the plain door marked by its small brass plate and nothing else.

Her eyes moved first to Ṛṣi.

Then to Maeril.

Then to the staff.

“You are leaving,” she said.

“Yes,” Ṛṣi answered.

“Today?”

“Yes.”

Selanka inclined her head.

Then she took a key from her belt and opened the door.

The room beyond was exactly as Ṛṣi remembered it.

That was not comforting.

Three narrow shelves. Three recessed cases at the far wall. Thick glass over slanted stands. Fine metal warding threaded into the frames with such care that the protection looked almost decorative until one understood better.

Maeril stepped inside and stopped.

Her eyes went to the cases first.

Lesser Impacts.

Greater Impacts.

Terminal Impressions.

She read them in order. Her mouth closed around whatever comment had tried to escape first.

Then she looked at the side shelves: warning registers, narrow folios tied in grey cord, reader accounts, and commentaries.

At last, she looked at Ṛṣi.

“Is this where all your ideas about dodging lightning bolts come from?”

“Not all of them.”

“That is not the reassuring answer you may think it is.”

Selanka closed the door behind them.

“No,” she said. “It is not.”

Maeril turned back to her.

Selanka’s face remained calm in the way a locked cabinet was calm.

“Seeker Ṛṣiśūra requested supervised access to The Art of Being Struck twenty-seven times.”

Ṛṣi lowered his eyes once.

“I did not count.”

“I did.”

Maeril stared at him.

Then at Selanka.

Then back at him.

“Twenty-seven.”

“Yes,” Selanka said.

Maeril’s tail moved once beneath her cloak, sharp and controlled.

Ṛṣi said, “Some entries required more than one session.”

“That explains the arithmetic and worsens the theology,” Maeril said.

Selanka crossed the room without answering and drew the drape aside.

The cloth made no sound.

Behind it, the chamber stopped pretending it had only ever been for books.

The padded room waited: low pallet, softened walls, open straps.

Maeril went very still.

Not with fear.

With assessment.

Ṛṣi knew that stillness. She had looked at failing wards that way.

She stepped closer, not touching anything.

The straps held her attention longest.

Then she breathed out through her nose.

“Do you know,” she said, very carefully, “I had begun to worry that spending half a season hunched over abjuration diagrams and arguing with invisible lines until I could hear them in my sleep was not entirely sane.”

Ṛṣi waited.

Maeril looked around the padded room.

Then back at him.

“I feel much better now.”

“It does look sane,” Ṛṣi said.

Selanka’s eyebrow moved.

Only a little.

Maeril pointed at him without looking away from the straps.

“Do not agree with me in that tone.”

“I will try.”

“You are failing.”

“Yes.”

Selanka let the drape fall back into place.

“You both chose difficult studies,” she said.

Maeril turned toward her.

“I chose difficult studies. He chose curated magical assault.”

“The distinction is not as large as you prefer.”

“I will consider that later.”

For a moment, the room held all three of them in the same quiet.

Selanka let the answer pass. Her gaze moved to the closed cases, then to the covered room behind the drape.

“The books stay,” she said. “So does the room.”

“What leaves?”

Ṛṣi looked at the glass.

“Awareness,” he said.

Selanka studied him.

Then nodded.

“Better than practice alone.”

His mouth moved slightly.

“I practiced that one first,” he answered.

Selanka’s expression softened.

Not warmly.

Enough.

Then she inclined her head.

That was all.

No embrace. No blessing shaped like softness. No praise warm enough to make leaving easier.

Only recognition placed exactly where it belonged.

Ṛṣi bowed to her respectfully.

“Thank you, Third Reader.”

Maeril, after a small hesitation, bowed as well.

“Thank you,” she said. “For supervising him through an amount of scholarly self-endangerment I am choosing not to imagine.”

“It was for a greater purpose,” Selanka said.

“Of course.”

“And professional interest.”

Selanka opened the door.

“May knowledge serve you well,” she offered at last.

They left the chamber together.


Master Olan’s farewell took place in the atelier because Maeril refused to have “a sentimental conversation in a corridor where anyone could be emotionally ambushed.”

Olan did not appear sentimental.

He stood beside the brass circle where the staff had been finished, hands folded into his sleeves, looking as if he had summoned them to discuss an error in the universe.

Maeril stood before him with her pack over one shoulder and her chin already lifted.

Ṛṣi had seen that posture often enough to know she was bracing for praise like incoming weather.

Olan looked first at the Staff of Warding.

Then at Maeril.

“The binding has remained stable?”

“Yes.”

“No unexpected discharge?”

“No.”

“No anomalous resonance, parasitic echo, delayed recoil, sympathetic bleeding, or spontaneous commentary?”

Maeril narrowed her eyes.

“Spontaneous commentary?”

“I included it as a precaution.”

“The staff has better manners than I do.”

“Yes.”

She stared.

Olan continued, mercilessly calm.

“The work is sound.”

Maeril went still.

Not much.

Enough.

Olan did not soften his voice. That would have been crueler, perhaps.

“It was ambitious, occasionally reckless, more expensive than I advised, and supervised under conditions I do not intend to repeat.”

“There it is,” she muttered.

“It was also precise. Unusually so. You did not force the warding to obey the theory. You altered the theory until the warding had a reason to hold.”

Maeril looked away first.

“That is called being right.”

“That is called learning.”

She opened her mouth.

Closed it.

Olan’s eyes warmed by a degree so small only Candlekeep could have measured it.

“Do not waste it.”

Her face changed.

The joke she had prepared did not survive.

“No,” she said. “I won’t.”

Olan inclined his head once.

Then, to Ṛṣi, “Do not test the staff casually.”

Ṛṣi bowed. “I will not.”

Maeril looked wounded. “Why does everyone assume we need that warning?”

Olan and Ṛṣi both looked at her.

She pointed at them.

“That was a rhetorical question.”

“Then choose better rhetoric,” Olan said.

Maeril’s laugh escaped before she could make it dignified.

Olan turned back toward his notes, which was his way of ending the farewell before it became obvious.

Maeril hesitated.

Then said, too quickly, “Thank you.”

Olan did not look up.

“You are welcome, Seeker Maeril.”

She turned before her face could betray anything worse.

But as they left the atelier, her hand brushed once against the carved channels of the Staff of Warding.

Not possessive.

Not checking.

Farewell, perhaps, to the place where fear had become work.


Lethan waited near the departure ledger with ink, sand, and the expression of a man determined not to feel anything where records could see.

The ledger was large enough to make even Maeril behave for almost three breaths. Names filled its pages in careful hands: Seekers admitted, Seekers released, books deposited, privileges granted, restrictions noted, fines levied, warnings issued, apologies extracted.

Maeril leaned over the page.

“Do not tell me I have accumulated a formal subtitle.”

“You have not,” Lethan said.

She looked disappointed.

“Several informal ones,” he added.

“Better.”

He turned the ledger toward them.

“Sign here. Both of you. This records the end of your current Seeker privilege and the return of all borrowed materials.”

“All?” Maeril asked.

Lethan looked at her.

“All.”

“It was a general question.”

“It was not.”

Ṛṣi signed first.

His hand moved carefully, the way it had when he first wrote his full name at the gate months ago. Then, it had been petition. Now, it was record.

Maeril signed beneath him with a flourish she would deny if asked.

Lethan sanded the page.

For a moment, none of them spoke.

Then he said, still looking down, “I have requested reassignment.”

Maeril stopped adjusting her satchel.

“Did we get you demoted?”

“No.”

“Promoted?”

“Worse.” Lethan closed the ledger. “Interested.”

Ṛṣi looked at him.

Lethan adjusted the edge of the book until it aligned perfectly with the table.

“There are field cataloguing assignments. Dangerous, inconvenient, frequently wet. I have applied.”

Maeril stared at him.

“Oh no,” she said softly. “We made you worse.”

“I believe the word is useful.”

Ṛṣi’s expression softened.

“Good.”

“That,” Lethan said, “is exactly the sort of response that caused this problem.”

Maeril pressed both hands to her chest.

“I am proud and horrified.”

“Then I have learned from excellent sources.”

She blinked.

Lethan looked immediately as if he regretted letting that sentence escape.

Too late.

Maeril’s face changed. Not into softness. She would never give him the satisfaction of softness in public. Into something brighter and more dangerous.

“Oh,” she said. “That was nearly affection.”

“It was clerical observation.”

“It was not.”

“It was.”

Ṛṣi said, “It can be both.”

Lethan sighed.

“I was afraid you would remain wise until the end.”

Maeril stepped forward and hugged him.

Lethan froze.

Then, with the stiff helplessness of a man attacked by gratitude, patted her shoulder once.

“Seeker Maeril.”

“Too late. Your paperwork cannot save you now.”

“I will file a complaint retroactively.”

“You do that.”

She released him.

Ṛṣi clasped Lethan’s forearm.

Lethan accepted that more easily, though his throat moved once before he spoke.

“Walk safely, Seeker Ṛṣi.”

“Walk usefully, Avowed Lethan.”

The novice’s mouth tightened at one corner.

“I will attempt not to perish in a ditch while identifying moss.”

“Start there,” Maeril said.

“I intend to.”

He opened the ledger again because apparently the page required urgent reinspection.

“Go,” he said. “Before this becomes completely undignified.”

Maeril lifted her chin.

“I was dignified.”

“No.”

“Fine. But memorable.”

“Yes,” Lethan said. “Unfortunately.”

They left him there with the ledger, the drying ink, and the future he had foolishly allowed to become less safe.


The postern gate did not look different.

That annoyed Maeril.

After two full seasons, several emotional crises, one dangerously intelligent door, a life-altering number of books, and enough warding theory to make her dream in circles, she felt the gate should have adjusted its presentation.

Perhaps a little glow.

A respectful creak.

A plaque.

Instead, the Avowed on duty checked their departure pass, opened the way, and wished them good roads with the calm of someone who had no idea that narrative weight was being mishandled.

Maeril stepped outside and turned back.

Candlekeep rose behind them in pale stone and height, wrapped in sea-wind, its towers and walls holding more than any view could admit. The Emerald Door could not be seen from here. That felt appropriate. Some thresholds stayed inside.

Ṛṣi stood beside her, pack settled, Staff of Warding in hand.

The old road waited beyond the rocks.

Not welcoming.

Roads rarely were.

Available.

That was enough.

Maeril drew a breath.

The air outside the walls was wilder than she remembered. Less filtered by books and wards and rules. It smelled of salt, wet grass, horse, distance, and all the terrible inconvenience of going somewhere.

“So,” she said, “do you still feel an urgent scholarly need to practice dodging fireballs?”

Ṛṣi did not answer at once.

He looked up instead.

Gulls moved above the cliffs, white against the pale morning. Sea-wind crossed the grass and brought salt with it, and somewhere beyond the rocks the old road waited in the thinning green between spring and summer.

“I enjoy this moment between spring and summer,” he said.

Maeril looked at him.

“I see. Dodging questions now, not spells?”

His teeth caught briefly at his lower lip.

“Safer.”

“Safer,” she agreed, smiling wide enough to make clear she did not intend to let him be safe from her.

For a moment, the road did not pull.

The wind moved around them. Candlekeep stood behind them. The staff rested in his hand, still new enough to be strange, no longer new enough to be only promise.

Then Maeril looked back toward the gate.

“I thought I would be happier to leave,” she said.

Ṛṣi looked toward the road.

“Are you unhappy?”

“No.” She frowned. “That is the problem. I am several things at once. It is inefficient.”

“Yes.”

She glanced at the staff.

“Still strange?”

“Yes.”

He turned it once in his hand.

The grip knew him.

The rest did not.

Not yet.

Its weight was honest. Its magic quiet. Its promise unsettling enough that he would not take it lightly.

Maeril watched his hand on the wraps.

“I meant what I said,” she said.

“I know.”

“If it saves you, do not apologize.”

“I remember.”

“Good. Because I will be very irritating about it.”

“You are often very irritating.”

“Yes, but with purpose.”

He looked at her then.

The sea-wind pulled a strand of hair across her face. She did not fix it. Her eyes were still on the staff, but her body leaned toward the road.

Toward whatever came next.

Behind them, the gate closed.

Not rejection.

Not refusal.

Only the end of one shelter.

Maeril reached for his free hand.

He gave it.

For a few steps, they walked that way: pack-straps creaking, boots finding the road again, Candlekeep at their backs, the Staff of Warding unfamiliar in his other hand.

The book stayed.

The staff went.

The road opened.

After a while, Maeril looked sidelong at him.

“If the staff starts giving you my opinions, you are to ignore at least half of them.”

“Which half?”

“The inconvenient half.”

“That may be difficult to identify.”

“Rude. Accurate. Continue.”

Ṛṣi’s fingers tightened once around hers.

The road bent south.

They followed it.

Canonical website for The Monk & The Witch: monkandwitch.com. If this text appears elsewhere with ads, payment gates, altered attribution, or misleading claims, it is not the canonical edition.

The Monk and the Witch is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. It is not approved or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. © Wizards of the Coast LLC.